Harringay online

Harringay, Haringey - So Good they Spelt it Twice!

Finally we have Haringey Council confirming that it was indeed regeneration director Lyn Garner who made the 'war zone' comments about Tottenham.

The defence of the indefensible is that the comments are being taken out of context and in any case were ( - you have to admire Nick Walkley's cheek) "specifically related to the appearance of one area during major disruptive works".

Yet, because I wasn't there at a private meeting ( aka the bus tour for councillors) and because nobody present when the insult was made has complained, then he is refusing to take further action.

In his reply to my formal complaint Mr Walkley said:

'Please be assured that had such a statement been made in the context which your email asserts this would be a matter of concern to me - that however is not the case.'

Anyway, the truth is out and on-the-record.

http://www.24dash.com/news/housing/2014-08-06-Tottenham-war-zone-co...

If the person leading on the regeneration of Tottenham is disparaging the area then how confident can people be that their views to not be bulldozed out of the way actually matters?

Views: 2283

▶ Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Well Mrs Peacock got hardly a slap on the wrists. What did you expect? I appreciate that because of her position this is a big deal but it's also free speech innit?

Hi John

It's what this remark may reveal about a mindset about Tottenham which is so worrying, especially since very senior officers in local authorities have power and influence. What is said in meetings and events is in a professional context. And senior managers manage large teams and their views carry weight and are likely to set the tone and culture. 

Zena Brabazon

Agree, Zena.

As a new councillor, I could have gone on the bus tour and would have, but a Surgery took  precedence. So I didn't hear the remarks: I hear secondary reports but in any event, the Chief Executive has now acknowledged that they happened.

I don't know what was the context.

However, we have heard before now, the excuse of taken out of context: –

There seems to be a lack of responsible leadership. The last Mayor made thoughtless, careless flippant remarks about Tottenham that were so crass, that they attained national publicity. A belated apology was so feeble that it was described as a faux-apology. At length and under pressure, a full apology was slipped onto a little-known council web page and was then claimed to have been published.

What might someone want to do with such a zone ?

  • Avoid it?
  • Bulldoze it?
  • Not fly planes over it?
  • Arm one side or another?
  • Research a Marshall Plan?
  • Send in foreign correspondents?
  • Observe that the rights of neutrals are suspended?

In the circumstances, one could forgive any Tottenham resident for feeling offence. (Civilians who live in one of the world's real war-zones would be entitled to take more offence).

But more than that, concern about what the remark discloses and may portend.

Zena your reflections 12 years ago on the  "war zone" remarks by the "officer" are no less pertinent or relevant today.

And does it not follow, that a local authority's chief executive officer has even greater power and influence to set the tone and culture?

For good or for ill. One has to wonder how many other senior officers knew of, or were part of, this council's written representations to the Government Regulator of Social Housing?

I notice that the faux outrage back then wasn't about the statement being untrue, only that it was said out loud. Over a decade later parts of Tottenham remain as described. The only things that have improved were a result of more affluent people moving in because they could no longer afford Stoke Newington or Harringay. Labour did nothing.

It's often instructive to put Clive's petty political grievances in the context of his own hypocrisy.

Here he is just days ago using 'Tottenham' as some kind of odd parochial slur. When he refers to a "Tottenham-dominated Labour Group".

Rather than parochial slur I would say it's a fact.

The Haringey Labour Party has been dominated by Marxists and their fellow travellers for decades and the movers and shakers among them have predominantly come from Tottenham and the east of Green Lanes (although admittedly not where they were really from). Think of such luminories of extreme left lunacy as Charles Adje, Emine Ibrahim and their like. Ironically, it was the parochialism of envy and distaste for the nicer things in the west of the Borough that led to their attempts to sell off Ally Pally and their determination to foist the enriching sub-cultural 'music' festivals upon people living within a mile of Finsbury Park.

Eric; yes. This local branch of Labour has often been an embarrassment to the national Party. Labour has some good people at national level, but at their Tottenham Branch, not so much. In my view, it needs sorting out.

When Charles Adje rammed through the 125-year Lease to the former slumlord—whose mobile number he had—he also managed to withhold vital information from his fellow Trustees.

The Chair's Briefing Note that he concealed had strongly advised against entering into a short-term Licence deal. For those interested in facts, details and evidence, I've attached it below. It was never meant to see the light of day. Adje disregarded the advice and you can judge it for yourself.

The Licence that he ordered fairly dripped with subsidies, incentives and inducements. Before the year 2007 was out, it would cost our Borough a huge sum, shocking the Chief Financial Officer when she learned of it.

I lodged a formal complaint. 18 months later, Standards suspended him as a Member for four months. For several subsequent elections, his local branch kept re-selecting him as a candidate. Over a more recent 36-month period, he played an outsized influential role in Joseph Ejiofor's Cabinet. Last year or the year before, he suddenly resigned.

The%20Briefing%20Note%20%28Holder%20to%20Adje%29.pdf

Also worth reading is former Labour Councillor Alan Stanton's excellent series titled, About Cllr Charles Adje.

.

Jamie! I'm afraid you are misguided over the claim of hypocrisy because you do not distinguish between ~

(a) the big district of Tottenham; and
(b) the Labour Party Branch in Tottenham (quite small, I hear)

The area has low voter turnout, although it certainly has been Haringey Labour's electoral base.

However, the two entities (area and Party) are not one and the same! I'm sure at least some Tottenham residents could point this out. Possibly, from among the sizeable majority who do not vote for any Party, including Labour.

I'm sure this was just a inadvertent slip in your normally careful and rigorous responses. I remain grateful for your continuing close attention.

.

The voter turnout was certainly embarrassingly low for you in Tottenham, Clive. Once the Lib Dems deselected you, your performance in the east of the borough seemed an appropriate gauge of your value to voters as a councillor.

I have no idea whether your lazy slight was conscious or otherwise, but you might want to be clearer with your language in future. Whichever your actual intended meaning, you put your friends Zena and Alan firmly in the firing line. 

FALSE: Once the Lib Dems deselected you …

Claire Kober (your chum?) also once attempted to perpetrate that falsehood.

Not all in the Tottenham Branch are bad eggs but as a whole, that Branch has been the main source of poor governance in our Borough for many years.

In May in Haringey it was Labour support overall that was in the firing line. In my view, the Tottenham Branch and the local Party needs to try to clean itself up.

Spot on.

RSS

Advertising

© 2026   Created by Hugh.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service